Warners Keeps On Battle Crying





When did Warner’s TV tail begin wagging their theatrical dogs? I’d submit not long after James Garner hit as Maverick. His launch as a feature star was Darby’s Rangers, also the last feature directed by William A. Wellman (Lafayette Escadrille was released later, but completed before, Darby’s Rangers). Bill’s being wild is better remembered than most films he made, thanks to anecdote-laden profiles done since he was active. Wellman made an unholy bargain with Jack Warner to guide routine shows in exchange for dream project Lafayette Escadrille, the latter recut and ruined by WB so as to neutralize a downer ending Wellman preferred. The routine assignment said to have barely engaged him was Darby’s Rangers. Warners has released that on an Archive DVD, at last in widescreen and looking very nice. Based on real-life wartime exploits, Darby's is less hard-hitting combat than opportunity for WB to audition television players on a larger canvas. A few of said youngsters click. Most evaporate. It was actually a smart idea to spin low-paid tube faces into longer forms. Jim Garner in a modestly budgeted feature drew teens that missed him over Maverick’s summer hiatus, and what 77 Sunset Strip fan could resist "Kookie" Byrnes on local theatre screens? Darby’s Rangers wasn’t cheap (negative cost: $1.6 million) and did return a half-million profit. We forget for a half-century’s distance how adroitly such pictures were sold and considerable interest home viewers had in seeing them. Warners salted ABC with spots for full-length butterflies emerged from series cocoons, and there were plenty once Darby's paid out. Viewers cared more then about Fort Dobbs, Up Periscope, and Yellowstone Kelly than do now, yet no product from the era better represents successful fusion of free and paying audiences. WB was first to draw patrons to ticket windows with personalities off television. We look at bonafide classic Rio Bravo today for reasons very different from those that separated 1959 customers from their coin. They cared barely a whit for Howard Hawks’ possessory credit, but Walter (Grandpa McCoy) Brennan, John (Lawman) Russell, Ward (Major Adams), and Ricky Nelson were something else again. For all our latter-day Rio Bravo analysis, we can never know what excitement a cast like that generated for first-runners, and how much television contributed to their enjoyment of Rio Bravo, Darby’s Rangers, and others that supped from video reservoirs.





Darby’s Rangers began as something more ambitious. Charlton Heston had agreed to star for a percentage of the gross. He wrote at the time of excitement over that deal, which for him amounted to membership in a very exclusive club. Jack Warner not unexpectedly reneged on the sharing and Heston withdrew, his lawsuit to follow. James Garner was then bumped to the lead. It’s likely the project was downgraded for lowered expectation now that untried-in-features talent was aboard. Most of Darby's was shot indoors, possibly reflecting Wellman’s age (well-worn early 60’s) and fatigue, plus Warner economizing. The director’s body was an arthritic roadmap of injuries sustained in daring youth as a WWI pilot, that service having propelled his since career as ruggedest of helmsmen. Edd Byrnes wrote in "Kookie" No More (engaging memoir) of Wellman rants and his discharging firearms on the set to discourage producer visits. Interesting how this sort of old Hollywood craziness was still tolerated on efficiency driven 1958 stages. Maybe Bill got a pass because studio veterans felt a little sorry for him, seeing aspects of their own uncertain futures in a noted director burning out. Wellman’s indifference to Darby’s Rangers seems odd for previous excellence handling similar The Story Of G.I. Joe and Battleground. Artificiality of his combatants firing on studio floors dressed as outdoor terrain had peculiar appeal, for Wellman gets effects he wants from such controlled environments (low-hanging fog almost like a horror set) that for me at least, convey more atmosphere than if Darby's had gone all-location.



















I suspect Warners dictated Battle Cry as guiding template for Darby's Rangers with less emphasis on war than sex, befitting crowd excitement over Here to Eternity bed-hopping by then standard issue in WWII subjects. Raoul Walsh’s 1955 brawler had seen five and a half million profit, reason enough to sell Darby’s Rangers along Battle Cry lines (note ad similarities here). WB wasn’t alone for shifting prominence from battlefield to boudoir. Robert Mitchum would spend less time fighter piloting than seducing officer’s wives in 1958's The Hunters for 20th Fox, while same year The Young Lions dealt far more with love action off front lines than combat thereon. Code restrictions being somewhat relaxed, Warners put uniforms on carnal Darby’s youth as lure for randy audience teens, with starlet discoveries sporting exotic names marquees barely got right. For these warriors, dodging Germans would be incidental to sampling French/Italian pastries that never said No. Wellman surely found all this insultingly childish, especially as he’d known real war and realized Darby's was prurient fantasy, but 50’s soldiering minus sex was nowheres-ville from a marketing standpoint. Vibrant youth idols weren’t to be wasted going stag into battle. Judging by sparse enemy presence in Darby’s Rangers, 1958 kids might have overlooked just who we were fighting, as there’s nary a close glimpse of adversaries in the field, let alone ones planning counter-offensive. Darby’s Rangers ended up being a war movie for audiences that didn’t much want to be bothered about whys and wherefores of war.



The Peter Pan War





Disney films for me represent happy times during an age of innocence. DVD look-backs emphasize joy of attending first-runs where turnstiles hummed and everyone whistled a merry tune. What actually went on behind showman curtains was not so idyllic. A Cold War in news headlines was mirrored by one fought near as ferocious by the industry’s mutually suspicious distribution and exhibition arms. Sometimes their war flashed hot. It seemed a non-stop game of one side trying to do in the other. Government sanctions broke up the trust that enabled film companies to control theatres in addition to producing and delivering movies, but home office powers were since nibbling around edges of the law to get back advantage they enjoyed when business was wide open and unrestricted. Independent showmen as ever took the brunt of policies squeezing them out of money generated by features expected to do well. Peter Pan was such an attraction and came along at a fraying point between opponents spoiling for battle. Distribution’s latest scheme was to pre-release better product for advanced admissions. Never mind that consent decrees entered into by the majors forbade such price fixing. Contracts were slippery and complicated, but end result found theatres forced to bump ticket rates in order to get pictures their customers wanted most to see. The policy had been applied to Quo Vadis, Ivanhoe, The Greatest Show On Earth, and a number of others. Exhibitor groups pointed out that more titles had been sold this way in an eighteen-month period than in ten years going before. Pre-releasing was merely a device for keeping top attractions in larger houses for longer runs and depriving small theatres of opportunity to compete with subsequent playing at lower prices. Favored venues tended to be those affiliated with powerful chains. They had muscle to negotiate terms and guarantee a profit. Regular runs at pet locations would follow pre-release engagements often in those same spots, ignoring clearances independent theatres depended on to differentiate their playing time from pricier first-runs. By the time affiliated powerhouses were done, attractions were not so attractive, as national promotion and drum beating was timed to key dates. Small auditoriums wound up with shows gone stale for their public.







Columbia led off 1953 with arm-twisting on behalf of highly touted Salome. They would pre-release the film only in cities of 75,000 or more, in effect foreclosing eighty percent of theatres across the country. Demands for increased admissions weren’t spelled out in booking contracts, but terms and guarantees made it impossible for showmen to run Salome unless they spiked ticket prices. The Allied Theatres group began drafting a complaint to the Department Of Justice. It was plain to them that film companies were colluding with powerful chains to starve little exhibitors out. By late March, producer Samuel Goldwyn was saying outright that Hans Christian Andersen would run only at advanced admissions, and if the exhibitors don’t like it, they don’t have to play it. Such incautious words aroused trade tempers and embarrassed distributor RKO, handler of both Goldwyn and Walt Disney output. Allied complainants were now looking for evidence of industry wrongdoing they could submit to the DOJ, with hearing dates set for April. A major smoking gun came courtesy the Walt Disney Company when a Cincinnati showmen defied Peter Pan pricing policy for an engagement beginning April 2. Rube Shor was a theatre/drive-in operator (and Allied spokesman) who’d had it up to here with high-handed treatment from distributors and decided to do something very public about it. His drive-in and hardtop ad appeared on the same Cincinnati Times-Star page (shown here) as day-and-date Peter Pan announcements from seven rival theatres. Those venues listed higher prices per expectation of Disney, including fifty cents at all times for children. Shor let kids in free at his Twin Drive-In and emphasized No Increase In Admission on his ad along with a shot at Disney heard round the exhibition world … The management feels since this is not a "Quo Vadis" or "The Greatest Show On Earth," in spite of demands made by distributor, that the families are entitled to this entertainment at "REGULAR PRICES." According to The Independent Film Journal, Shor’s competitors suffered for the comparison, as ticket sales for the seven opposition screens were down. Disney sent Shor a telegram that same day and minced no words. The admission prices that you are advertising in today’s Cincinnati papers fail to meet the conditions of our approval and renders the approval ineffective. Seems Disney had booked Peter Pan with what they referred to as a specific understanding that Rube Shor would charge the same increased prices as other "pre-release" engagements in Cincinnati. But wait, wasn’t this price fixing in violation of the Consent Decrees? We understand that you have already received possession of prints of "Peter Pan" and this is to advise you that no print of Peter Pan" may be exhibited except under a contract approved by us and exhibition without such a contract would constitute a copyright infringement with serious penalties.












Disney reminded Shor of specific ticket prices he was expected to charge. They also sent the telegram to his managers and warned them of personal liability for participating in copyright violation. Shor’s reply defended his right to charge whatever admission he saw fit for Peter Pan and that suggestions to the contrary from Disney or RKO amounted to their willful violation of anti-trust laws. In fact, Disney’s wire had implicated RKO in a violation of the Government’s anti-trust decree. Here was ammunition to go before the hearing board in Washington on April 15, with Disney’s telegram Exhibit A for complainants at Allied. Leo Samuels, the Disney sales supervisor who sent the wire, was suddenly backing off. We are not attempting to tell any exhibitor what to charge for "Peter Pan." We don’t care if he lets patrons in free, but we have a right to license the exhibition of our pictures as we see fit and to expect payment on that basis regardless of the theatre’s admission charges. That’s the exhibitor’s prerogative, not ours. Samuels added that he knew nothing about reports that RKO was asking exhibitors to put their admission prices in writing before contracts were signed. That got RKO skittish and assistant sales manager Walter Branson declared: We can’t make any statement. It’s all up to Disney. Meanwhile, Peter Pan was going into second runs at the same increased prices. Witnesses before the Senate committee said flat out that divorcement of producing and distributing from exhibition didn’t take, and maybe it was time to further separate producer companies from their distribution arms. Words like conspiracy and collusion were applied to industry distribution practices, with independent theatres helpless to operate for the benefit of small communities. One manager in Netcong, NJ testified that RKO wanted sixty percent of his Peter Pan receipts and even withdrew the booking after it had already been advertised. Walt Disney himself was in New York for a weekend and was asked about the controversy. Walt wondered how exhibitors expected a producer to spend three million on a picture produced especially for children and then not be given a chance to get his costs back. Disney said he’d not been informed of Rube Shor’s refusal to boost prices for Peter Pan, but that the showman might be in trouble if he violated his contract with RKO. In any case, Walt concluded, it was an issue for RKO’s sales department to work out.

























A campaign in favor of the public was what some exhibitors called a movement to stop inflated ticket prices and so-called pre-releases. National Alled was telling members not to rely on representations from RKO salesmen and supervisors, since without Disney’s stamp of approval, they had no real authority to confirm deals on Peter Pan. As hearings went into late April, rebuttal of Allied member testimony came from representatives of Loew’s and Universal: Where exhibitors find it possible to get together with their competitors, they either divide our pictures between themselves without consulting us, or they assign our pictures to one of the theatres in the locality in accordance with their ideas. We often find ourselves assigned to a second or third class theatre, which we do not like at all, because it greatly reduces our possibility of earnings, and, we feel, eliminates a free market. RKO was also there to claim that what exhibitors called pre-releases was merely deluxe marketing. As for Rube Shor’s under-12 free policy on Peter Pan, that was nothing more than a showman’s attempt to cash in on increased concession sales by using the film as a loss leader. Admit youngsters gratis and they’d more than make it up at the candy counter. RKO also distanced itself from Disney in saying that the threatening telegram had been sent on the producer’s own initiative without ever consulting us (could this move have entered into Disney’s decision within the year to leave RKO and set up his own distribution arm?). Harrison’s Reports dismissed all of this as mere subterfuge. Companies were fixing prices but carefully keeping such agreements out of written contracts so as to appear within compliance of anti-trust regulations. This sort of don’t ask/don’t tell was hard to regulate when obtuse showmen spilled beans as here when Boise, Idaho’s Pinney Theatre listed Nationally Established Admission Prices For "Peter Pan" in large print. It seemed few took worthwhile lesson from the confrontation. RKO came to Rube Shor later that summer with its terms for Hans Christian Andersen. He would tender thirty-two cents for each adult ticket sold and sixteen cents for every child. That was as good as forcing Shor and other exhibitors to increase their prices in order to pay the amounts specified. Whatever remedies were proposed or instituted gave little relief to showmen down the line. I pulled up the Liberty’s somewhat belated November 1953 run of Peter Pan and prices were inflated there as well, children’s seats being thirty cents when they were ordinarily a dime. This Is The Minimum Price This Program Can Be Shown, said Colonel Forehand in small print. Ironically, the product-split referred to by distributors was common practice between our Liberty and Allen Theatres. In ordinary circumstances, the Allen ran whatever of RKO came to town, except in the case of Peter Pan and Hans Christian Andersen. Both of those played the Liberty, and at increased admissions. I’d assume that Mr. Allen refused RKO’s terms, and Col. Forehand took both by default (the Liberty and Allen were our only hardtops circa 1953).



They Dood It Twice





Do catchphrases catch on anymore? I’m too far off the popular culture beam to have any idea. Sometimes I’ll use antiquated expressions to mostly bemused response. The cleverest of them still work. Others are best left moldering. I Faw Down and Go Boom (explored previously here) is among the latter. Rusty-thatched ribber (yes, someone actually called him that) Red Skelton had trunkfulls. His radio show pitched a plethora against walls hoping some would stick. One that did (and how!) was uttered by Skelton alter ego The Mean Widdle Kid. If I Dood It, I Get a Lickin’ … (he does it) … I Dood It! Get it? Now make for the streets and repeat (often) to passerbys. Will you get a lickin’? Sure nuff. They’ll dood it! I think I need a break from this doodling. Maybe an in-patient one (and Word’s spell check is tripping over my repeated use of Dood … It’s Murder, I Say!). Then-kids must have been plenty obnoxious about the house after listening to Skelton. I’m pretty insufferable here just for having watched I Dood It, then revisiting some of Red's radio programs. How pervasive was this line? Well, the day after Lieutenant Colonel James H. Doolittle raided Tokyo on April 18, 1942, many headlines read Doolittle Dood It. Cartoons, mostly from Warners, pillaged the phrase and near wore it out. Ann and I watched No Time For Love last week and Fred MacMurray borrowed it. Then of course, MGM signed Red and ultimately made a wartime hodgepodge in swingtime called … well, naturally it was called … I Dood It. Warner’s Archive is recently out with that. Those who want an intense 40’s pop culture injection need look no further. And that’s a complement, by the way. I like entertainment so topical as to exclude most everyone nowadays watching, especially when it’s zeroed in on eras I prefer to my own. Just get with the I Dood It program, forget its inanities, and savor the air of those whose days and nights were spent following Hit Parades of the moment, be they radio, bandstands, or song sheets from which this show derived (and vice versa).








I Dood It had story origins in Buster Keaton’s Spite Marriage. The set-up never appealed to me for undercurrents of cruelty running through Buster/Red’s relationship with respective femme partners (Dorothy Sebastian in 1929, Eleanor Powell for 1943). Girl marries boy to spite (hence original title) the (unworthy) man she prefers almost till narrative’s end. Both involve wedding nights unconsummated and lead comics mistreated by unsympathetic leading ladies they’re unaccountably daffy over. Operating on a life’s assumption that buffoons have feelings too, I’m off-put seeing Buster/Red treated this way, especially as both versions redouble antagonists (bootleggers in Spite Marriage, saboteurs in I Dood It). The dreaded Elmer in Keaton was incubating as this last of his silent features glimpsed the departing Buster of yore, providing (just) enough worthwhile comedy to make Spite Marriage fun. Only Keaton’s vigilance prevented its sinking altogether into plot contrivance that would in fact swamp I Dood It. Singularly ironic was Keaton toiling in both versions, the first as lead star, the second as wage-earning "gag consultant." Was that his job description with MGM as of 1943? I’d like to see the contract, if there even was one. Keaton tells in his memoirs of Eddie Mannix starting him at $100 per week around the late thirties. Before long I was getting $300 a week, he recalled. Buster’s function was on the lot trouble-shooting. He sat in an office, often idle, and waited for someone (anyone) to call down and summon him to fix humor deprived bits. Bright spots we got in many Metro comedies (and light action romances like Too Hot To Handle) were courtesy Keaton applying laugh support. He was appalled by non-existent work ethics of comics under contract, but took an interest in Red Skelton and saw there a talent to climb places top-liners like himself once scaled. Would Metro let Keaton guide Red to clowning greatness?



















The answer was an expected No. Buster wrote of his conference with Louis Mayer. The comedian had never articulated a position with such fervor and eloquence, all that wasted before a man committed most to keeping a now lowly staff employee in his proper place. Sad to think of all the useful ideas Keaton offered during the forties to so few that listened. He was brought onto I Dood It to help Red Skelton recreate some routines Buster had performed in Spite Marriage. Uncredited, of course. You never saw Keaton’s name in a Metro 40’s credit save odd occasion when he was supporting onscreen, for example In The Good Old Summertime, or as director of a few shorts Louis Lewyn produced and Metro distributed. A crueler jab I found was in The Lion’s Roar, a lavish magazine MGM published at the time covering I Dood It for benefit of exhibitors and whatever fans came across it. They devoted a section to one Wilkie Mahoney, a specialist in streamlined humor who’s devoting all his energies to the happy task of making Red Skelton fans explode with longer and louder guffaws. I thought at first this guy might be a nom-de-plume for Keaton, but no, there really was a Wilkie Mahoney and, according to the imdb, he worked around MGM at the time. Said Metro: He was responsible for most of the gags in "I Dood It," and if the reaction of preview audiences is accurate, scored a series of bulls-eyes. Mahoney was said to be adding piquant sauce to comedy scenes, his stated aversion the gag-pilferer, the gentleman of flexible standards who is content to pass off someone else's creation as his own. Such poseurs ... don't even belong in the outskirts of burlesque. Well put, Wilkie, but did they belong on the same lot with Buster Keaton, taking bows for work this humbled genius was doing sans recognition other than a living wage? What a place was Metro. As Keaton’s suggestions got a bum’s rush out of every executive office, publicists there were extolling Wilkie Mahoney as an exceptionally useful citizen to have around.







































MGM was oiled thick enough to sell anything by the forties, with music a soothing accompaniment. I Dood It plugged songs and the songs plugged I Dood It. The rest, including Skelton’s foolery, mattered less. All Metro’s comedies from that period Pied Piped to banks shaped like jukeboxes. Every clown from Abbott and Costello to the Marx Brothers boosted tunes, for these sold way round mere perimeters of a theatre. Awareness was assured by planting melodies months in advance of opening, per MGM’s relationship with the Leo Feist, Jr. publishing firm, a promotional juggernaut that made Metro’s own publicity unit seem like pikers. Feist was Tin Pan Alley Headquarters and generated hits through relentless power of suggestion. You could reasonably add a quarter-million to a feature’s take for songs therein that clicked. Getting on "most played" lists at music stores and radio stations was a process carefully manipulated once tunes were set for upcoming Metro pics. I never realized what a sap I’d been for imagining I picked favorites on my own. How long has this been going on? Since recorded sound began, apparently. Star Eyes was the I Dood It number picked to go places. Evidently, it did, because I still hear it often on Sirius 40’s satellite radio, not realizing it began life in a Red Skelton movie. The swooner crooner shown here is Don Saxon of broadcast station WHN. He’s testing faint inducing potential of Star Eyes on a Bevy of Beauty (note girl’s wrists and ankles wired to the Swoon Meter). I could be cynical and deplore such mass-hypnotism, but this kind of spirited salesmanship is hard not to like.


































I’ll not leave the topic of I Dood It without mentioning Eleanor Powell. She dances up an absolute storm in this. There’s a particular number with lassoes (So Long, Sarah Jane). If someone tried it today, they’d need CGI, and afterward CPR. For that, the woman rehearsed sixteen weeks. I don’t think this is publicity blab either. Faux talents in High School Musical Three pulling off such a routine would be hoisted upon shoulders to collect a special Oscar. Amazing how miracles were so taken for granted then. Metro oddly reused several set-pieces out of prior Honolulu and Born To Dance to augment Powell’s dance card in I Dood It. Was she so exhausted from her rope tricks (worth getting the DVD just for that, by the way)? Director Vincente Minnelli (surprisingly) didn’t take credit for this highlight. He was assigned I Dood It in the wake of successful first film Cabin In The Sky and noted (in his book) Skelton’s insecurity. I’m not funny, cried the comedian during rushes. So is Red funny? I never found him notably so, even as a ten year old (me, not him) watching CBS on (to best recollection) Tuesday nights. There was something lachrymose about those God Bless sign-offs, worse when he’d check out for summer break (one year being so emotional I thought he was leaving for good). The features work better for me, and there are pretty good ones. Excuse My Dust warrants Warner Archive release (Red’s character could almost be Dean Stockwell’s Happy Years neighbor, so alike are pics in setting and costume). Watch The Birdie is interesting. Red, as a camera store employee, at one point checks out Clark Gable in Boom Town on 16mm (!). Much of WTB borrowed from The Cameraman. Buster Keaton had a hand in most all the Skeltons, Wilkie Mahoney’s useful citizenship notwithstanding.